Senior cat food vs adult cat food: what's actually different

Senior cat foods are close to adult cat foods. Across 37 senior and 227 adult dry foods, the middle senior food is about the same in calories per kilogram and about the same in protein per calorie. The differences that do show up are small.

MedianAdult, drySenior, dryAdult, wetSenior, wet
Calories, kcal per kg3,676 (178)3,670 (31)942 (251)941 (47)
Calories, kcal per cup406 (167)420 (28)68 (10)– (0)
Protein, g/1,000 kcal92.6 (227)89.9 (37)95.9 (266)101.8 (54)
Fat, g/1,000 kcal41.6 (227)39.8 (37)42.5 (266)44.3 (54)
Fiber, g/1,000 kcal12.1 (225)12.5 (37)11.7 (266)10.6 (54)
Carbohydrate, % of calories28 (226)30 (37)14 (247)15 (53)
Phosphorus, mg/100 kcal207 (35)176 (12)199 (67)175 (21)
Sodium, mg/100 kcal124 (34)100 (9)126 (67)108 (15)

Medians of the foods' label figures, with the number of foods behind each in brackets (fewer than 5 shows as –). Phosphorus and sodium count only foods whose maker gives a typical or maximum value, not just a guaranteed minimum. Prescription diets are left out.

"Senior" has no nutrient definition

US cat foods are formulated to AAFCO's nutrient profiles, which cover growth and reproduction, and adult maintenance. There's no senior profile, so a senior cat food is an adult food its maker chose to call senior.

Calories, protein and fat

The middle senior dry food has 3,670 kcal per kilogram against 3,676 for adult foods, and 420 kcal per cup against 406. Protein is 89.9 g per 1,000 kcal against 92.6 g, both well above AAFCO's adult minimum of 65 g, and fat is 5% lower. In wet food, senior recipes are 6% higher in protein (101.8 g against 95.9 g). If your older cat is gaining or losing weight, the calorie statement on the label matters more than the word senior.

Phosphorus and sodium

Phosphorus matters for older cats because kidney disease is common in them. Tufts University's nutrition team, reviewing published data, found senior cat foods no lower in phosphorus than adult foods. In our label data, from the foods whose makers give a typical value, the middle senior dry food has 176 mg per 100 kcal against 207 mg, and senior wet food 175 against 199. That's from few foods, and far above the 150 mg or less suggested for cats with early kidney disease. For those, see low-phosphorus cat food and kidney diets for cats compared.

Carbohydrate

Senior dry foods get 30% of their calories from carbohydrate against 28% for adult dry foods, and wet foods much less either way: see carbs in wet and dry cat food.

Choosing a food for an older cat

Choose for what your cat needs rather than for the word senior, and ask your vet, who can check kidney values and weight at a senior checkup. Don't switch a healthy cat to a kidney diet without that advice.

Sources