Prescription weight-loss diets for dogs and cats compared

When a vet puts a dog or cat on a diet, the usual prescription foods come from Hill's (Metabolic, r/d and w/d), Royal Canin (Satiety Support and Weight Control), Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets (OM) and Blue Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet (W+M for dogs, W+U for cats). Here they are side by side, with what veterinary guidelines say about losing weight safely.

Never starve a cat. A cat that loses weight too fast, or stops eating, can develop fatty liver disease (hepatic lipidosis), which can be fatal. If your cat won't eat its diet food, call your vet about another one.

Why a weight-loss diet, not less of the usual food

A food's protein, vitamins and minerals are balanced to its calories, so feeding less of it cuts them along with the calories (Tufts, 2018). When researchers modeled feeding five ordinary dog foods at weight-loss calorie levels, every one fell short of at least one nutrient, most often choline and selenium (Linder and colleagues, 2012). Weight-loss diets are made for eating less: they're fortified, with more nutrients per calorie, more protein to help keep muscle and more fiber for fullness (AAHA, 2021). The Merck Veterinary Manual advises against simply feeding less of a maintenance diet, and Sanderson, a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, advises against non-prescription weight-management foods for weight-loss programs (2019).

How fast is safe

About 1 to 2% of body weight a week for dogs and 0.5 to 2% for cats (AAHA, 2018; Tufts, 2018), and slower is fine. For a 60 lb dog that's 0.6 to 1.2 lb a week; for a 12 lb cat, about 1 to 4 ounces. Merck aims for about 1% a week, with a weigh-in every two weeks, and the vet adjusts the calories as the weigh-ins come in. In practice, pets often lose more slowly than that, and loss slows over time (German, 2016).

The numbers

31 dog diets and 31 cat diets, dry first, then wet, each from the fewest calories per kg. Nutrients are per 1,000 kcal, so you can see what a pet gets at a given calorie target. Values from the makers' product guides and pages are typical values; ~ marks a midpoint of a label's minimum and maximum, ≥ a minimum and ≤ a maximum.

Dogs

FoodFormkcal per kgCaloriesProtein, g/1,000 kcalFiber, g/1,000 kcalFat, g/1,000 kcal
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Multifunction Adult Dry Dog Food - Satiety + Hydrolyzed Proteindry2,699232 per cup≥104~60.8≥27.8
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Satiety Support Adult Small Breed Dry Dog Fooddry2,873224 per cup≥97.5~49.4≥26.1
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Multifunction Adult Dry Dog Food - Urinary + Satiety, Chickendry2,897243 per cup≥96.7≤57.6≥25.9
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Satiety Support Adult Dry Dog Food - Weight Managementdry2,911224 per cup11564.436.4
Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Overweight Management Canine Formula (Dry)dry2,918258 per 8-oz cup99.636.921.9
Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Select Blend Overweight Management Canine Formuladry2,941219 per 8-oz cup10033.321.8
Hill's Prescription Diet r/d Chicken Flavor Dry Dog Fooddry2,943242 per cup10545.326.7
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Multifunction Adult Dry Dog Food - Advanced Mobility Support + Satietydry2,997246 per cup≥86.8~51.7≥31.7
Hill's Prescription Diet w/d Multi-Benefit Dry Dog Fooddry3,087254 per cup60.042.334.7
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic Lamb Meal & Rice Formula Dry Dog Fooddry3,094254 per cup80.939.633.6
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic Chicken Flavor Dog Fooddry3,124257 per cup82.540.134.5
Hill's Prescription Diet c/d Multicare + Metabolic Weight Dry Dog Fooddry3,147277 per cup82.343.936.7
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic + Mobility, Weight + Joint Care Chicken Flavor Dry Dog Fooddry3,173288 per cup81.440.739.2
Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Metabolic Response + Joint Mobility Canine Formuladry3,250285 per 8-oz cup14816.135.2
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Canine Weight Control Large Dog Adult Dry Dog Fooddry3,287270 per cup83.821.032.9
Blue Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet W+M Weight & Mobility Support Adult Dog Dry Food - Chicdry3,294331 per cup≥91.1~27.3≥39.5
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Advanced Mobility Support + Satiety Drydry––10256.541.9
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Satiety + Hydrolyzed Protein Dry (Dog)dry––12072.337.9
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Satiety Support Weight Management Small Dog Drydry––11053.034.7
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Urinary SO + Satiety Dry (Dog)dry––11154.335.1
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Weight Control Medium Dog Drydry––83.520.932.8
Hill's Prescription Diet w/d Multi-Benefit Vegetable & Chicken Stew Dog Foodwet578204 per can64.142.630.5
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Satiety Support Weight Management Adult Dog Loaf in Sauce Wet Foodwet592225 per can10620.032.4
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic Weight + j/d Vegetable & Tuna Stew Dog Foodwet635224 per can82.247.344.1
Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Overweight Management Canine Formula (Canned)wet663249 per 13.3-oz can13058.735.3
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic Vegetable & Chicken Stew Dog Foodwet700247 per can84.033.633.0
Hill's Prescription Diet w/d Multi-Benefit Chicken Flavor Wet Dog Foodwet824304 per can56.640.233.4
Hill's Prescription Diet r/d Chicken Flavor Wet Dog Foodwet854298 per can10238.326.1
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic Chicken Flavor Wet Dog Foodwet888328 per can80.842.737.5
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Urinary SO + Satiety Loaf in Saucewet––13247.941.3
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Weight Control Loaf in Sauce (Dog)wet––89.67.431.6

Cats

FoodFormkcal per kgCaloriesProtein, g/1,000 kcalFiber, g/1,000 kcalFat, g/1,000 kcal
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Multifunction Adult Dry Cat Food - Urinary SO + Satietydry2,904238 per cup≥110≤52.0~29.3
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Feline Satiety Support Adult Dry Cat Fooddry2,914230 per cup≥110≤57.0~30.9
Hill's Prescription Diet r/d Chicken Flavor Dry Cat Fooddry2,956268 per cup11244.527.8
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Multifunction Adult Dry Cat Food - Satiety + Hydrolyzed Proteindry3,016238 per cup≥106~44.4≥27.2
Hill's Prescription Diet w/d Multi-Benefit Dry Cat Fooddry3,225293 per cup11617.626.7
Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Overweight Management Feline Formuladry3,241286 per 8-oz cup15918.428.2
Hill's Prescription Diet c/d Multicare Stress + Metabolic Weight Chicken Flavor Dry Cat Fooddry3,242285 per cup11238.635.1
Blue Buffalo Blue Natural Veterinary Diet W+U Weight Management Adult Cat Dry Food - Chickendry3,257352 per cup≥117~20.7≥33.8
Hill's Prescription Diet c/d Multicare + Metabolic Weightdry3,379297 per cup11130.537.2
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic Weight + j/d Cat Fooddry3,380374 per cup11227.435.5
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic Chicken Flavor Dry Cat Fooddry3,398299 per cup10727.337.3
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Satiety + Hydrolyzed Protein Dry (Cat)dry––10746.029.9
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Satiety Support Weight Management Drydry––10945.128.8
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Urinary SO + Satiety Dry (Cat)dry––11041.929.0
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Weight Control Drydry––10426.729.6
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Feline Satiety Support Weight Management Adult Cat Loaf in Sauce Wet Food –wet58585 per can1187.933.1
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Multifunction Adult Wet Cat Food - Urinary SO + Satiety + Calmwet60588 per can≥102≤36.4≥24.8
Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Savory Selects Overweight Management Feline Formula With Chicken In Sauce Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Savory Selects Overweight Management Feline Formula With Turkey In Sauce (With Chicken)wet729–14222.438.7
Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Savory Selects Overweight Management Feline Formula With Salmon In Saucewet735114 per 5.5-oz can14122.039.5
Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Overweight Management Feline Formula With Ocean Whitefish and Chicken In Saucewet738115 per 5.5-oz can13635.435.2
Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Savory Selects Overweight Management Feline Formula With Chicken In Sauce Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Savory Selects Overweight Management Feline Formula With Turkey In Sauce (With Turkey)wet748–14321.736.1
Hill's Prescription Diet c/d Multicare + Metabolic Weight Vegetable & Chicken Stew Cat Foodwet76262 per can10529.739.6
Hill's Prescription Diet c/d Multicare + Metabolic Vegetable, Tuna & Chicken Stew Cat Foodwet76360 per pouch10529.839.4
Hill's Prescription Diet r/d Chicken Flavor Cat Foodwet778121 per can11148.736.0
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic Vegetables & Chicken Stew Cat Foodwet78464 per can10826.236.8
Hill's Prescription Diet w/d Multi-Benefit with Chicken Wet Cat Foodwet821128 per can11440.539.6
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic Chicken Flavor Wet Cat Foodwet873136 per can10729.538.4
Hill's Prescription Diet Metabolic weight + j/d Vegetable and Tuna Wet Cat Foodwet87872 per 2.9 oz 82 g can11422.634.1
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Satiety Support Weight Management Thin Slices in Gravywet––1159.434.5
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Urinary SO + Satiety + Calm Loaf in Saucewet––12018.746.7
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Weight Control Loaf in Sauce (Cat)wet––11910.730.8

What stands out

  • Fewer calories per cup. The dry diets here have 2,699 to 3,294 kcal per kg for dogs and 2,904 to 3,398 for cats, against medians of 3,642 and 3,756 for regular dry dog and cat food on this site. A bigger portion for the same calories helps a pet feel fed.
  • Protein is high per calorie. Most of the dog diets have 80 g or more per 1,000 kcal, and every cat diet has 100 g or more, well above AAFCO's adult minimums of 45 and 65. Hill's w/d for dogs is the lowest, at about 57 to 64.
  • Fiber varies the most, from under 10 to over 70 g per 1,000 kcal. Some wet versions show far less crude fiber than the same brand's kibble: crude fiber misses soluble fiber, which made up a bigger share of total fiber in canned dog foods than in dry ones in one study (Farcas and colleagues, 2013). Measured as total fiber, weight-loss diets for dogs have about 75 to 110 g per 1,000 kcal (Moreno and colleagues, 2022).
  • Many do two jobs. Several combine weight loss with urinary care (Hill's c/d Multicare + Metabolic, Royal Canin Urinary SO + Satiety, Blue Buffalo W+U), joint support (Hill's Metabolic + Mobility, Purina OM Metabolic Response + Joint Mobility, Blue Buffalo W+M) or a hydrolyzed protein (Royal Canin Satiety + Hydrolyzed Protein). Your vet weighs all of your pet's conditions.
  • Calories per cup or can differ, and the table shows them. The vet's calorie target comes to a different number of cups for each food, so check before switching, and keep treats under 10% of the day's calories (Merck). The treat budget calculator has a setting for dogs on a vet's weight-loss plan.

Cats need extra care

In cats, losing weight too fast can cause hepatic lipidosis: fat is broken down faster than the liver can handle it, which can lead to liver failure (Tufts, 2018). Obese cats on a weight-loss plan are at higher risk, so they must keep eating enough, and a cat that refuses its diet food should be switched to another (Merck). Any illness or stress that stops a cat eating can set it off, including a diet it won't accept, and Merck suggests checking a liver enzyme (ALP) during weight loss, so the plan can be paused if it rises. Dogs aren't at much risk of it (AAHA, 2018).

Choosing between them

That's your vet's call, with you. The vet sets the target weight and the calories, checks for conditions that change the choice, such as diabetes, kidney disease or arthritis, and rechecks every couple of weeks. These diets need your vet's authorization to buy. Each food's page has its full analysis, minerals and ingredients: click its name in the table.

Sources