Wet vs dry cat food: how much carbohydrate?

Across 669 dry and 893 wet cat foods, the middle dry food gets 28% of its calories from carbohydrate and the middle wet food 12%. 50% of the wet foods meet the 12% level that feline diabetes guidelines suggest, against 7% of the dry ones.

0%10%20%30%3% between 0 and 520% between 0 and 503% between 5 and 1022% between 5 and 103% between 10 and 1518% between 10 and 15108% between 15 and 2016% between 15 and 2022% between 20 and 2511% between 20 and 252025% between 25 and 308% between 25 and 3020% between 30 and 355% between 30 and 353012% between 35 and 401% between 35 and 404% between 40 and 450% between 40 and 45401% between 45 and 500% between 45 and 50% of calories from carbohydrate
  • Dry (669 foods)
  • Wet (893 foods)
Share of each form's cat foods, by the share of their calories from carbohydrate.
The numbers
% of calories from carbohydrateDryWet
0–53%20%
5–103%22%
10–153%18%
15–208%16%
20–2522%11%
25–3025%8%
30–3520%5%
35–4012%1%
40–454%0%
45+1%0%

Why dry food carries more

Kibble needs starch to hold together through the cooker that shapes it, so dry foods start from more carbohydrate. Wet foods can be mostly meat and water. That's why the ISFM and AAHA diabetes guidelines prefer wet food for diabetic cats, and why the Tufts nutrition team says canned food is often, but not always, lower in carbohydrate.

"Not always" matters: the chart's wet bars reach well past 20%, from gravies thickened with starch and recipes with rice, potato or peas. And a few dry foods are low.

The lowest-carbohydrate dry foods

For cats that won't eat wet food, these dry foods have the smallest share of calories from carbohydrate. Low-carb dry foods tend to be rich in calories, so measure portions.

The full list, wet and dry, is on the low-carb cat food page.

How the carbohydrate is worked out

US labels don't list carbohydrate, so it's estimated as what's left after protein, fat, fiber, moisture and ash, then turned into a share of calories with the same factors the calorie statement uses (how we calculate). From a guaranteed analysis the estimate can run a little high or low; foods whose label figures don't add up are left out of these numbers.

Does it matter for a healthy cat?

The 12% level comes from guidelines for diabetic cats, and even there the best level isn't settled. For a healthy cat, the evidence is thinner; ask your vet whether carbohydrate matters for yours. For a cat that's overweight, total calories matter as much as where they come from.

Sources