Prescription urinary diets for dogs and cats compared
Prescription urinary diets for dogs and cats from Hill's (c/d Multicare and u/d), Royal Canin (Urinary SO and UC), Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets (UR), Farmina (Vet Life Urinary) and Blue Buffalo (W+U), side by side, with what veterinary guidelines say about choosing one.
Start with a diagnosis. Struvite and calcium oxalate stones need opposite urine conditions, so the wrong diet can work against the stone your pet actually has. Your vet finds out which it is with urine tests, imaging and, once a stone is out, stone analysis.
What a label can't show
Urinary diets work by changing urine: how acidic it is, how dilute, and how saturated with the minerals stones are made of. That saturation, called relative supersaturation (RSS), is measured in urine collected from animals eating the food, not in the food itself (FDA, 2024). It depends on the whole recipe, including acidifiers, protein, sodium and moisture, and on how much the animal drinks, so the guaranteed analysis can't predict it (Morris and colleagues, 2023; ACVIM, 2016). The tables below show nutrients you can compare, not how well a diet works.
RSS is itself only a stand-in for stones forming, the ACVIM panel cautions. In a study funded by Hill's, urinary cat foods gave healthy cats much lower struvite supersaturation than ordinary cat foods did, but not clearly lower calcium oxalate supersaturation (Morris and colleagues, 2023).
Struvite and calcium oxalate need different things
- Struvite stones can usually be dissolved. Dissolving diets are low in magnesium and phosphorus and make urine more acidic (ACVIM, 2016; Merck). In dogs, struvite usually comes with a urinary infection, which needs an antibiotic chosen by urine culture; once the infection is gone, a long-term diet isn't needed (Merck). During dissolution the diet is fed with no other food or treats, with rechecks every few weeks (Merck).
- Calcium oxalate stones can't be dissolved; they're removed, and they often come back (Merck; ACVIM). Prevention aims for dilute urine that isn't too acidic: wet food with more than 75% water, or water added to kibble, no acidifying foods, and no excess animal protein. More than 10 g of animal protein per 100 kcal, which is 100 g per 1,000 kcal, was linked to more calcium in urine (ACVIM, 2016); the tables give total protein.
Making urine acidic discourages struvite but may favor calcium oxalate in susceptible cats (FDA, 2024). After cat foods moved to less magnesium and more acidifying recipes, calcium oxalate went from 2% of cat stones sent for analysis in 1981 to 41% in 2007 (Morris and colleagues, 2023).
The numbers
32 dog diets and 46 cat diets, dry first, then wet. Magnesium, phosphorus and sodium are per 100 kcal, and protein per 1,000 kcal. Values from the makers' product guides and pages are typical values; ~ marks a midpoint of a label's minimum and maximum, ≥ a minimum and ≤ a maximum.
Dogs
Cats
What stands out
- Sodium differs the most. Typical values in the dry diets run from 50 to 350 mg per 100 kcal for dogs and from 69 to 390 for cats. Some diets add sodium so pets drink more and make more dilute urine (Merck). The ACVIM panel cautions that a high-sodium dry food, over 375 mg per 100 kcal, is no substitute for wet food in preventing calcium oxalate, because its effect seems to fade within 3 to 6 months. If your dog also has heart disease, ask your vet about sodium: the low-sodium list shows which diets are under 80 mg.
- Magnesium is kept low, which guards against struvite. In the Hill's-funded study, urinary cat foods averaged 0.07% magnesium on a dry-matter basis, against 0.11% in other cat foods (Morris and colleagues, 2023).
- Hill's u/d stands apart for dogs, with much less protein and phosphorus than the rest: about 30 g of protein per 1,000 kcal. Protein-restricted diets like it are used for some stone types, under a vet's care (Merck; ACVIM).
- Wet versions bring water, which dilutes urine. That's the main lever against calcium oxalate, and the ACVIM panel suggests foods with more than 75% water for it.
Store-bought "urinary" cat foods
Some non-prescription foods for adult cats carry a urinary claim. FDA's 2024 guidance says such a claim can rest on feeding studies that measure RSS for both struvite and calcium oxalate, and suggests wording such as "Promotes a healthy mineral content in the urinary tract". That's a claim about healthy adult cats, not a treatment for stones, and RSS can't be checked from a label.
Choosing between them
That's your vet's call, once the stone type or urinary problem is known. Prescription diets are sold through or under the direction of a vet because owners can't diagnose these conditions themselves (FDA). Each food's page has its full analysis, minerals and ingredients: click its name in the table.
Sources
- Lulich JP et al. ACVIM Small Animal Consensus Recommendations on the Treatment and Prevention of Uroliths in Dogs and Cats. Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine, 2016.
- Van Vertloo L. Urolithiasis in Dogs and Urolithiasis in Cats. Merck Veterinary Manual, 2026.
- FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine. Guidance for Industry #284: Using Relative Supersaturation to Support "Urinary Tract Health" Claims for Adult Maintenance Cat Food, 2024.
- FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine. CPG Sec. 690.150: Labeling and Marketing of Dog and Cat Food Diets Intended to Diagnose, Cure, Mitigate, Treat, or Prevent Diseases, 2016.
- Morris EM et al. Relative supersaturation values distinguish between feline urinary and non-urinary foods and align with expected urine analytes contributions to uroliths. Frontiers in Veterinary Science, 2023. Funded by Hill's.
- The makers' product guides and pages, linked from each food's page.