Prescription low-fat dog foods compared

When a vet prescribes a low-fat diet, for pancreatitis, high blood fats or some gut conditions, the usual choices are Hill's Prescription Diet i/d Low Fat, Royal Canin Gastrointestinal Low Fat, Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets EN Low Fat and Blue Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet GI Low Fat. Here they are side by side.

The numbers

11 dry and wet versions, per 1,000 kcal so dry and wet compare fairly. Values from the makers' product guides and pages are typical values; ~ marks a midpoint of a label's minimum and maximum, ≥ a minimum.

What stands out

  • They're closer than their marketing. The dry versions sit near 20 g of fat per 1,000 kcal, all under the 25 g that veterinary nutrition references call low fat, and some at or under the 20 g the Merck Veterinary Manual suggests for dogs with pancreatitis. See the low-fat list for where those limits come from.
  • Protein varies more than fat. Per 1,000 kcal, protein ranges widely across these diets, which matters for a dog that also needs to keep muscle, or one with kidney concerns.
  • Wet versions aren't always leaner. Per 1,000 kcal, some cans carry a little more fat than the same diet's kibble, though each can holds fewer calories.
  • Calories per cup differ, so switching from one diet to another at the same number of cups changes how much a dog eats. Check the calories per cup or can before switching.

Choosing between them

That's your vet's call, with you. All four are made for the same job, and the differences above, along with which one your dog will actually eat, are what usually decide it. These diets need your vet's authorization to buy, and dogs that have had pancreatitis or have high blood fats need their diet chosen and followed up with a vet.

Each food's page has its full analysis, minerals and ingredients: click its name in the table.

Sources